Draft review

Each practice draft next to the rewrite, with the mistakes highlighted and the reasoning behind each score. Scores are estimates, not official CELPIP ratings.

#DraftTimeWordsEstimate
1Blender complaint email (Task 1, formal)17 / 27 min1828-9
2Outdoor cinema survey (Task 2)25 / 26 min196~9
3Heating email to landlord (Task 1, formal)15 / 27 min190~9
4Thank-you email to a friend (Task 1, informal)11 / 27 min177~9
5Bus lanes survey (Task 2)18 / 26 min1618-9

The patterns across all five drafts, and the proofreading checklist built from them, are in the cheat sheet.

Punctuation and mechanics Grammar Word choice Content or prompt mismatch

Numbers in the draft match the numbered fixes below it.

1. Blender complaint email

Task 1, formalNov 1617 of 27 min182 wordsEstimate 8-9
You bought a blender online and it stopped working after two uses. Write to customer service.
  • Describe the product and when you bought it
  • Explain the issue
  • Say how it has inconvenienced you
  • Request a specific solution

My draft

Dear Customer Service Team,

The purpose of my writing today is to raise an issue with a Ninja Pro Max blender that I purchased1 from your website on Nov 5th, 20262.

I used the appliance as a daily driver3 in my regular cooking -4 to blend vegetables, whole spices, sometimes protein shakes and smoothies;5 until it stopped working6 after a couple of uses.

I've had to rely on makeshift recipes that don't require the use of7 a blender,8 for my meals this past week. I purchased this high-end blender because it's known to be the best in its category;9 and more importantly, reliable. It's quite frustrating to see your10 day come to a stand still11 if an appliance that's supposed to make your life easier,12 ends up making it more difficult.

As I understand it, the blender came with a 1 year13 warranty;14 and since I'm well within that window, I'd like to return it for a full-refund15. Should you require any additional insight16 or supporting documentation, please rest assured that I remain readily available to provide it17.

Yours sincerely18,
Tom Hanks

Rewrite

Dear Customer Service Team,

I am writing about a Ninja Pro Max blender that I bought from your website on November 5, 2026 (order number 48213).

I planned to use the blender every day to blend vegetables, whole spices, protein shakes, and smoothies. However, after only two uses, the motor stopped running, and the blender no longer turns on, even when it is plugged into a different outlet.

This has caused me real inconvenience. For the past week, I have had to rely on simple recipes that do not need a blender, and I have spent extra time preparing meals. I chose this model because it is known to be reliable, so I am quite disappointed that it failed so soon.

The blender is covered by a one-year warranty, and I am well within that period. I would like to return it for a full refund. Please let me know how to send it back. I am happy to provide photos or any other documents you need, and I would appreciate a reply within five business days.

Sincerely,
Tom Hanks

Why this score

DimensionEstimateReason
Task Fulfillment9-10All four points covered, right tone, one clear request.
Content/Coherence9Good organization, but the failure is vague and "daily driver" contradicts "two uses".
Vocabulary8-9"Makeshift" and "supporting documentation" are good. "Additional insight" and "rest assured that I remain readily available" are stiff.
Readability8Three misused semicolons, a spaced hyphen as a dash, a comma between subject and verb.
  1. 1Word"Purchased" appears twice. Vary it: "bought".
  2. 2Mechanics"Nov 5th, 2026" → "November 5, 2026".
  3. 3Content"Daily driver" contradicts the prompt: it only worked twice.
  4. 4PunctuationA spaced hyphen is not a dash. Use a comma or a colon.
  5. 5PunctuationSemicolon before "until": wrong, because "until it stopped" is not a full sentence.
  6. 6ContentToo vague. Say what failed: "the motor stopped running and it no longer turns on".
  7. 7Word"Require the use of" is wordy: "need".
  8. 8PunctuationNo comma before "for my meals".
  9. 9PunctuationSemicolon before "and": wrong.
  10. 10GrammarSwitches to "your" (second person) in a letter about you.
  11. 11SpellingThe noun is one word: "standstill".
  12. 12PunctuationComma between the subject ("an appliance that...") and its verb ("ends up").
  13. 13Mechanics"1 year" → "one-year" before a noun.
  14. 14PunctuationSemicolon before "and since": wrong.
  15. 15Spelling"Full refund" has no hyphen.
  16. 16Word"Additional insight" → "information".
  17. 17WordStiff. "I am happy to provide photos or receipts."
  18. 18Word"Yours sincerely" pairs with a named person. With "Dear Customer Service Team", use "Sincerely" or "Kind regards".

2. Outdoor cinema survey

Task 2Nov 1625 of 26 min196 wordsEstimate ~9
Your city wants to encourage community engagement. Option A: a multipurpose sports field. Option B: a public outdoor cinema for weekly screenings and cultural events. Choose one and give at least two reasons.

My draft

I believe that a public outdoor cinema would be the better choice. This is primarily because of how inclusive it is and the exposure it provides1.

To begin with, a public outdoor cinema naturally becomes a communal hub where people meet and talk. For instance, having a movie screening about World War 12 or a cultural Diwali celebration would not only be an escape from the mundane daily life3 but also teach them4 about important history and culture.

Another important consideration is inclusivity. People from all age groups and financial backgrounds can enjoy the events at the outdoor cinema.5

Although a sports field has its advantages, particularly the fact that it will encourage youngsters to be more athletic6, it may not be as effective because sports activities are logistically challenging, in that they require you to coordinate a time with 2 groups7 of people who intend to play against each other. It's more restrictive towards older people who tend to have mobility issues, and hence cannot participate. Some sports require formal training too.8

For these reasons, I strongly believe that a public outdoor cinema would be the most practical and beneficial choice for encouraging community engagement.

Rewrite

I would choose the outdoor cinema because it brings neighbours together and welcomes everyone in the community.

First, an outdoor cinema creates a shared space where residents meet and talk. A weekly screening of a documentary about World War I, or a film night around Diwali, would give people an evening out while teaching them about history and culture. After the show, many would stay and chat, which is exactly the kind of community engagement the city wants.

Second, it is open to everyone. Seniors with mobility problems can sit comfortably and enjoy a film, which they could not do on a sports field. Families on a tight budget also benefit, since a public screening costs far less than the $15 or more that a cinema ticket costs every week. A student or a retired person on a fixed income can attend as easily as anyone else.

A sports field would help young people stay active, but it mostly serves people who are fit and can organize a group to play.

For these reasons, I believe the outdoor cinema is the more practical choice for building community in our city.

Why this score

DimensionEstimateReason
Task Fulfillment9-10Choice stated first, two reasons, comparison, conclusion.
Content/Coherence8-9The Diwali and World War I example is vivid, but reason 2 is thin and the comparison runs 74 words.
Vocabulary8-9"Communal hub", "logistically challenging", "mobility issues" are good. "The exposure it provides" is vague.
Readability8-9Mostly clean, no misused semicolons.
  1. 1Content"Exposure" to what? Also, the intro lists the reasons in a different order than the body (hub, then inclusivity).
  2. 2Mechanics"World War I" or "the First World War".
  3. 3GrammarDrop "the": "an escape from mundane daily life".
  4. 4Grammar"Them" has no clear referent. Use "residents".
  5. 5ContentReason 2 is two generic sentences with no concrete detail. The seniors and budget points belong here.
  6. 6WordWordy. "A sports field would help young people stay active."
  7. 7MechanicsWrite one to nine as words: "two groups".
  8. 8ContentThe comparison is 74 words with three drawbacks. Keep the strongest in one sentence and move the rest into your reasons.

3. Heating email to landlord

Task 1, formalNov 1815 of 27 min190 wordsEstimate ~9
The heating in your apartment stopped working three days ago, and the weather is getting colder. You called the building office once, but nobody came.
  • Describe the problem and when it started
  • Explain how it is affecting you and your household
  • Say what you want the landlord to do, and by when

My draft

Dear Ms. Kay,

I am writing to raise a very important issue1 regarding the apartment's heating.

The unit's heating system stopped functioning on 15th Nov at around 2pm2. I noticed this when it started feeling chilly inside which3 is unusual around this time of day. Upon checking, I noticed4 that the reading showed 17 degrees celsius5, which is concerningly low compared to the 22 degrees that I usually keep it at.

As a result, I promptly called the building office to get it looked at6, and while they assured me that they'd send someone by end of day;7 it's been two days8 and nobody has come to the apartment, or contacted me for next steps.

Fall is around the corner9, and I'm not used to such cold temperatures as I come from a warmer climate. I've already started feeling feverish because how cold10 the thermostat is running11.

I would appreciate it if you could reach out to the building management or a private company to take a look at this and get this resolved12 by this weekend, as the forecast suggests a much colder week ahead.

Yours sincerely,
John Doe

Rewrite

Dear Ms. Kay,

I am writing about an urgent problem with the heating in my apartment, unit 4B.

The heating stopped working on November 15 at around 2 p.m. I noticed the apartment felt unusually cold, and the thermostat showed 17 degrees Celsius, well below the 22 degrees I normally keep it at. I called the building office that afternoon, and although they promised to send someone by the end of the day, nobody has come or contacted me in the three days since.

This is affecting my health and my daily routine. I come from a warmer climate, so I am not used to these temperatures, and I have already started to feel unwell. I now wear a winter jacket indoors and cannot work from home comfortably.

Winter is approaching, and the forecast shows a much colder week ahead. Could you please arrange for a technician to repair the heating by this Saturday? If that is not possible, I would appreciate a portable heater in the meantime.

Yours sincerely,
John Doe

Why this score

DimensionEstimateReason
Task Fulfillment9All three bullets, formal tone, deadline with a reason. "Two days" contradicts the prompt's three.
Content/Coherence9-10Concrete details (2 p.m., 17 vs 22 degrees), logical order, clear request.
Vocabulary9"Promptly", "concerningly low", "upon checking" are good. "A very important issue" and "get it looked at" are weak or casual.
Readability8A misused semicolon, a missing comma, "because how", the date format.
  1. 1Word"A very important issue" → "an urgent issue".
  2. 2Mechanics"November 15 at around 2 p.m."
  3. 3PunctuationComma before "which" when it adds extra information: "chilly inside, which is unusual".
  4. 4Word"Noticed" twice in two sentences. Use "found".
  5. 5Spelling"Celsius" takes a capital C.
  6. 6Word"Get it looked at" is casual for a formal email.
  7. 7PunctuationSemicolon misused. "Although they promised..., nobody has come."
  8. 8PromptThe prompt says three days.
  9. 9ContentIt is November, so it is already fall. "Winter is approaching."
  10. 10Grammar"Because of how cold".
  11. 11WordA thermostat does not run cold. "How cold the apartment is."
  12. 12WordWordy, "this" twice. "Arrange for a technician to repair the heating."

Contractions (they'd, it's, I'm) are acceptable. The official Level 9 sample uses "I'm" in a formal email.

4. Thank-you email to a friend

Task 1, informalNov 1811 of 27 min177 wordsEstimate ~9
A friend spent a whole weekend helping you move into your new apartment.
  • Thank your friend and describe what they did
  • Explain how their help made a difference
  • Suggest a way to thank them in person

My draft

Dear Max,

I hope you're doing well. It's been a while since we last caught up.1

I've finally settled into my new place and wanted to reach out to thank you for taking the whole weekend out2 last month to help me move. You not only helped with packing my things up3 into boxes, but also helped pick them up and load them into the back of the truck.

If that wasn't enough4, you went above and beyond by driving me and my stuff to the new place and carrying the boxes up to the new apartment. If it wasn't for that, I'd be left5 with no option but to hire a moving and packing company whose bill would have run exorbitantly high6.

I would like to take you out for a nice dinner and drinks this Saturday to make it up to you7 for all your help and for being such a good friend, as always. Let me know if that works for you and8 I'll make the reservation. Looking forward to it!

Take care9
Karan

Rewrite

Hi Max,

I hope you've recovered from all that lifting! I've finally unpacked the last box, and I wanted to properly thank you for giving up your whole weekend to help me move.

You did so much more than I expected. You helped me pack everything into boxes, loaded all thirty of them into the truck, and then drove me across town to the new place. On top of that, you carried the heaviest boxes up three flights of stairs, including my bookshelf and that old couch.

Honestly, I don't know what I would have done without you. If you hadn't helped, I would have had to hire a moving company, which would have cost at least $800. Because we finished on Sunday evening, I was also able to start my new job on Monday feeling rested instead of stressed.

To thank you, I'd love to take you out for dinner and drinks this Saturday at that Thai place you like. Let me know if that works for you, and I'll make the reservation.

Take care,
Karan

Why this score

DimensionEstimateReason
Task Fulfillment9All bullets, warm tone, specific invitation. Bullet 2 is one hypothetical sentence, and the opener does not fit a recent weekend together.
Content/Coherence9Clear sequence (pack, load, drive, carry), but no numbers or specifics.
Vocabulary9"Went above and beyond" is good. "Make it up to you" is the wrong idiom, and "helped" appears three times.
Readability8-9No semicolons. A past "if" sentence in the wrong tense, an idiom error, missing commas.
  1. 1ContentTemplate opener that does not fit: you saw Max recently. "I hope you've recovered from all that lifting!"
  2. 2Word"Giving up your whole weekend".
  3. 3Word"Helped" three times. "You packed my things into boxes, then loaded them into the truck."
  4. 4GrammarFixed expression: "As if that weren't enough".
  5. 5GrammarPast "if" sentence: "If it hadn't been for you, I would have had no option".
  6. 6Word"Would have cost a fortune", or better, a number: "at least $800".
  7. 7Word"Make it up to you" is for apologizing. For thanks: "to thank you".
  8. 8PunctuationComma before "and" when it joins two full sentences.
  9. 9Punctuation"Take care," with a comma.

5. Bus lanes survey

Task 2Nov 1818 of 26 min161 wordsEstimate 8-9
Your city has money for one transit project. Option A: bus-only lanes on the busiest roads. Option B: reduce all bus fares by 10%. Choose one and explain your reasons.

My draft

To make public transit more attractive, I believe creating bus-only lanes on the busiest roads1 is the better option for two reasons. Not only does it save time, but also contributes2 towards reducing pollution in the city.

Firstly, dedicated bus lanes on the busiest roads would drastically reduce commute times3. This would be beneficial for office workers and school goers4 in particular, as they run on strict schedules.

On top of that, more people opting for public transit5 would result in fewer private vehicles on the road releasing pollution-causing gases and smoke into the atmosphere6, leading to cleaner air to breathe.

Although reducing bus fares by 10% would help make public transit more lucrative7, it won't influence the public decision as strongly, because most of these civilians8 can afford to own a car anyway9, so the decision seems to be more about convenience over10 cost.

For these reasons, I believe creating bus-only lanes on busy roads is a more effective approach.

Rewrite

I believe bus-only lanes are the better way to make public transit more attractive, because they would save riders time and help reduce pollution.

First, separate lanes would make buses much faster during rush hour. Right now, a bus on a busy downtown street sits in the same traffic as every car, so a 20-minute trip can easily take 45 minutes. With its own lane, the bus could move past the traffic and stay on schedule. This matters most for office workers and students, who cannot afford to arrive late.

Second, faster buses would convince more drivers to leave their cars at home. If the bus is quicker than driving, many commuters will switch, and fewer cars on the road means less exhaust and cleaner air for everyone in the city.

A 10% fare cut would save regular riders some money, but it would only take about 33 cents off a $3.30 fare, which is unlikely to change how people travel.

For these reasons, I believe bus-only lanes would do more to make public transit attractive for everyone in our city.

Why this score

DimensionEstimateReason
Task Fulfillment9Clear choice, on-topic reasons, calm one-sentence comparison, conclusion. 161 words is at the low end.
Content/Coherence8No concrete example anywhere. Reason 2 is one sentence and assumes people will switch without saying why.
Vocabulary8-9"Lucrative" and "civilians" misused. The prompt's wording is copied three times.
Readability9No semicolons, clear paragraphs. Two grammar slips.
  1. 1WordCopied from the prompt, three times in total. The pack says to avoid overusing the question's words. "Bus-only lanes" or "separate bus lanes" is enough.
  2. 2Grammar"Not only does it save time, but it also helps reduce pollution." The second half needs "it".
  3. 3ContentAdd a number: "a 45-minute ride downtown could drop to 25 minutes".
  4. 4Word"School goers" → "students".
  5. 5ContentMissing step. Why would more people take the bus? "Faster buses would convince drivers to switch."
  6. 6WordWordy. "Exhaust".
  7. 7Word"Lucrative" means profitable for whoever earns the money. You mean "affordable" or "appealing".
  8. 8Word"Civilians" means people who are not in the military. Use "residents" or "commuters".
  9. 9ContentA guess about other people that a rater may not accept. A number is stronger: "it only takes about 33 cents off a $3.30 fare".
  10. 10Grammar"More about convenience than cost". "More" pairs with "than".